Anthelminthic properties of Methylene chloride-methanol (1:1) extracts of two Cameroonians medicinal plants on Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidea)
BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine volume 17, Article number: 400 (2017)
The resistance of some medico-veterinary parasite strains as well as the unavailability and toxicity of synthetic anthelminthics on humans, animals and the impacts of their residues in the environment have pushed scientists to turn to plants with anthelminthic properties. Hence, the aim of this work was to contribute to the fight against helminths of medical and veterinary importance in general, and also to clear the environment of their free living stages.
Fresh eggs of Heligmosomoides bakeri were obtained from the faeces of experimentally infected mice. L1 and L2 larval stages were obtained after 48 and 72 h of coproculture respectively. Methylene Chloride-Methanol (1:1) extracts of Annona senegalensis and Nauclea latifolia were diluted in DMSO or Tween 80 to prepare the following concentrations: 625, 1250, 2500, 3750 and 5000 μg/ml. The effects of extract solutions were evaluated on the embryonation of eggs, egg hatching and on L1 and L2 survival after 48, 10 and 24 h of incubation. Negative controls were 1.5% DMSO, 4% Tween 80 and a mixture of these solvents. The TLC was carried out and the profiles of secondary metabolites were made.
Negative controls had no effect on the embryonation, eggs hatching and on larval mortality. However, it was found that, the extracts affected the free living stages of H. bakeri in a concentration-dependant manner. At the highest concentration (5000 μg/ml), the rate of inhibition of embryonation obtained were 20.80%, 38.15% and 84.83% for Methylene Chloride-Methanol of Annona senegalensis (MCM As), Nauclea latifolia (MCM Nl) extracts and mixture of Annona senegalensis and Nauclea latifolia (MCM As-Nl) extract respectively. For egg hatch, the inhibition rate was 16.10%, 46.24% and 87.07% for the above three extracts respectively at the same concentration of 5000 μg/ml. On L1 and L2 larval stages after 24 h of exposure to extracts, the mortality rates of 100%, 54.76% and 96.77% against 98%, 51.44% and 100% were obtained for MCM As, MCM Nl and MCM As-Nl respectively at the highest concentration. The Methylene Chloride-Methanol of A.senegalensis, N. latifolia extracts showed the presence of alkaloids except in N. latifolia extract, flavonoids, sterols, triterpens, tanins, polyphenols, anthraquinons, saponins and terpenoids.
These findings suggest that, the mixture of the two plant extracts showed an additive (synergetic effect) ovicidal effect and a slight larval mortality on L1 as compared to the effect of MCM As extract alone. These effects were due to the presence ao secondary metabolites identifies in the plant extracts. Thus, they may be used as possible «disinfectants» for soil transmitted nematodes.
Infection by gastrointestinal helminths constitutes a serious public health problem especially in developing countries where climatic factors (heat and humidity), poverty and the poor hygienic condition influence the proliferation of disease [1,2,3]. In tropical areas, human helminthosis is counted among the first seven parasitic diseases registered as Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTD) , whereas they shackle the health of over two million of people worldwide. In Cameroon, more than 10 million people of a total of 16.1 were infested by these parasites in 2004 . In infested hosts, the disease can create malnutrition, anemia, asthenia, lethargy, and anorexia which compromise human and animal health . In addition, helminthosis affect growth and intellectual development and increase the vulnerability of school age children to other diseases. In livestock, these affections affect the reproduction, weight, milk and meat production. These ailments frequently cause death in heavily infested hosts, resulting in enormous economic losses [7, 8]. Actually, several methods of helminthosis control exist and the most frequently used are chemotherapy and phytotherapy. This is often done through the use of synthetic anthelminthic combined with the management of pasture [9, 10] in developed countries while it is done by medicinal plants with anthelminthic properties in developing countries . Many plants are used worldwide for multiple purposes; in Cameroon for example, Annona senegalensis and Nauclea latifolia are two medicinal plants from two different families used in traditional medicine not only for many ailments but also for abdominal pain and in particular for de-worming. The aim of this study was to evaluate the ovicidal and larvicidal activities of Methylene Chloride-Methanol of A. senegalensis and N. latifolia extracts and their mixture on Heligmosomoides bakeri in order to assess the synergistic or antagonistic effects of the mixture in view to monitor the free living stages of nematodes and finally to prevent host infections.
All parts (roots, stem bark, fruits and leaves) of shrubs of the two selected plants were harvested from the peripheral savannas of Foumbam in the Noun Division of the West Region of Cameroon. These plant parts were transferred to the National Herbarium of Cameroon (NHC) for authentification. The plant specimens were first identified by Nnomo Laurent a botanist of the Department of Plant Biology of the Faculty of Science of the University of Dschang as Annona senegalensis Pers, 1934 and Nauclea latifolia Smith, 1919 (Sarcocephalus latifolius Bruce) and were registered later respectively under numbers 43,530/NHC and 47,652/NHC at the NHC. Plant stem barks of each species were dried in the shade for 1 to 6 h per day, ground to powder form and stored in separate airtight plastic bags in the Research Unit of Biology and Applied Ecology (LABEA) for further use.
Obtention and preparation of plant extract
The procedure used to obtain the different plant extracts was according to Wabo Poné et al.  and D’Angelo et al. . Briefly, two hundred (200) grams of the stem barks powder were macerated in 3 l of Methylene Chloride-Methanol mixture (1:1) to maximize the yield of the extraction. The mixture was kept in the laboratory for seventy two (72) hours. During this period, it was stirred daily to speed up the extraction process. It was then filtered successively through two metallic sieves (mesh sizes: 500 μm and 150 μm), a layer of cotton and filter paper (Joseph N° 1). The last filtrates were then evaporated in a rotavapor (Model Büch-R-124). The extract obtained was poured in 4 inox plates and kept in the oven at 45 °C for 24 h for full evaporation of the solvent. Each plant extract was separately diluted and mixed volume per volume at the start of the experiment. For this, two hundred (200) mg of each extract were dissolved separately in 0.8 ml of Tween 80 and 0.3 ml of DMSO (to facilitate the mixing with water). Distilled water was added to the diluted extracts in a 100 ml beaker to bring the volume up to 20 ml, thus obtaining a stock solution of 10,000 μg/ml. Through serial dilutions, concentrations of 5000, 3750, 2500, 1250 and 625 μg/ml were made. 4% Tween 80 and 1.5% DMSO were used as negative controls. Methylene Chloride-Methanol extraction yields were 9.5 and 10% for A. senegalensis and N. latifolia respectively.
Recovery of nematode eggs and larvae
Fresh eggs of Heligmosomoides bakeri obtained from the faeces of experimentally infected mice were put to coproculture for 36–48 h and 72–96 h to obtain L1 and L2 larvae respectively .
Evaluation of the effect of extracts on different free stages of parasite
The methodology used in this part was the routine procedure used in the Research Unit of Biology and Applied of University of Dschang. All treatments had four replicates. For these manipulations, the experimental design proposed by Wabo Poné  is shows in Fig. 1.
Evaluation of ovicidal effect of extracts
The effect of the extract on eggs was evaluated in terms of embryonation of fresh eggs and hatching of embryonated eggs.
For embryonation, 1 ml of suspension containing 30 to 40 fresh eggs was introduced in 6 Petri dishes. Thereafter, 1 ml of different concentration of single plant species was added to the Petri dishes (for the mixed extract, 0.5 ml for MCM As and 0.5 ml for MCM Nl). After 48 h of incubation time, the inhibition rate of embryonation (IRE) was estimated using the following formula (1):
For the egg hatch test, the same procedure was used except that the eggs were allowed to embryonate first (24 h after the recovery) and the inhibition rate of their hatching (IRH) was evaluated 10 h later by the following formula (2):
Hatching was stopped by added 2–3 drops of 5% Lugol when 90% of the egg hatched in control . Thus, the inhibition rate of eggs hatching was fixed at 10% for negative control and treated groups.
Evaluation of the larvicidal effect of extracts
One (1) ml of suspension containing 10 to 15 L1 or L2 larvae was introduced in 6 Petri dishes. Then, 1 ml of each concentration of extract was added in a Petri dish (for the mixed extract, 0.5 ml for MCM As and 0.5 ml for MCM Nl). Twenty four (24) hours later the larvicidal effect of the extract was evaluated. Mortality rate (MR) was then estimated by the following formula (3):
(a larva was considered dead if it was observed immobile and with a straight body for 5 to 10 s).
‘qualitative phytochemical screening and thin layer chromatography (TLC) profile of extracts
Secondary metabolites contained in the extracts were determined using colorimetric methods. For the separation of different phytochemical compounds in the Methylene Chloride-Methanol (1:1) extracts of A. snegalensis and N. latifolia the extracts were spotted manually using a capillary tube on precoated silicagel G TLC plates (15 X 5 cm with 3 mm thickness). The spotted plate was put into a solvent system Ethyl Acetate- methanol- water (95: 5: 2) to detect the suitable mobile phase; 10% sulphuric acid reagent was used to identify the respective compounds.
Inhibitory and lethal concentrations 50 (IC50 and LC50) were determined using the regression line drawn in excel according to the decimal logarithm of concentration and mortality of probits. The mean embryonation inhibition, hatching inhibition and mortality rates were also compared using the chi-square test at the P < 0.05 significance level.
Irrespective of the free living stage considered, the negative controls i.e. 4% Tween 80, 1.5% DMSO and 2% Tween 80–0.75% DMSO, had no effect on it. However, the different extracts at different concentrations had different effects on the fresh eggs, embryonated eggs and on L1 and L2 larval survival.
Effect of extracts on eggs
Table 1 shows the variation of the rate of inhibition of embryonation according to different concentrations. The effects of different extracts were concentration-dependent. At the highest concentration (5000 μg/ml), the inhibition rate of embryonation of the mixture extract (MCM As-Nl) was significantly (P < 0.05) higher (84.83%) as compared to the effect of MCM As extract (20.8%) and MCM Nl extract (16.1%).
Table 2 shows that the rate of the inhibition of eggs hatching rises with the increasing of extract concentration. At the highest concentration (5000 μg/ml), the mixed extract produced an inhibition rate of 87.04% while the single species extracts gave lower rates [MCM As extract (38.15%) and MCM Nl extract (46.24%)].
Effect of extracts on larvae
Table 3 presents the variation of mortalities rates of L1 larvae according to different extract concentrations. It is observed that, mortality rates also rise with the increasing extract concentration. The effect of MCM As extract was the most efficient, producing a mortality rate of 100% against 96.77% and 54.2% for MCM As-Nl and MCM Nl respectively at the highest concentration (5000 μg/ml).
As on fresh and embryonated eggs, the effect of the combined extracts was also efficient on L2 (Table 4). At the highest concentration (5000 μg/ml) the mortality rates obtained were 52.44%, 98% and 100% for MCM Nl, MCM As and MCM As-Nl extracts respectively.
Qualitative phytochemical screening and thin layer chromatography (TLC) profile of the extracts
Table 5 presents the secondary metabolites contained in Methylene Chloride-Methanol (1:1) extracts of A. senegalensis and N. latifolia differentiated based on their colours. All the secondary metabolites identified are present in the extracts except for alkaloids absent in MCM Nl.
The Methylene Chloride-Methanol (1:1) extracts of A. senegalensis and N. latifolia.extract were subjected to TLC, different compositions of the mobile phase were tried in order to separate the different secondary metabolites (Table 5, Fig. 2a and b). The samples were spotted on the TLC plates which were developed in the appropriate solvent system. The study revealed bioactive compounds in the stem barks extracts of A. senegalensis and N. latifolia.
The main advantages of using in vitro assays to test the anti-parasitic properties of plant extracts include low cost and rapid turnover which allow the screening of plants on a large scale. These tests measure the effect of anthelminthic activity directly on the processes of development, hatching and motility of parasites [14,15,16]. The inhibition of embryonation rates and egg hatching rates obtained in controls were very low. These results are similar to those obtained by Payne et al. . According to Katiki et al. , DMSO and Tween 80 are two diluents mostly used for the screening of new anti-parasitic substances because these diluents are tolerated by eggs and larvae of nematode in low concentration. In general, the activity of extracts increases with the rise in concentrations. It had been proposed that an increase in concentration brings about a supplementary input of different active compounds resulting in higher effects .
The effect of MCM As and MCM Nl extracts were less active on embryonation and egg hatching of H. bakeri as compared to the effect of the mixed extract. Indeed, this is in agreement with D’Angelo et al.  who tested MCM As extract on the same parasite. On the other hand, Ngangout et al.  using aqueous and ethanolic extracts of N. latifolia and A. senegalensis respectively on H. bakeri eggs obtained contrary result. The difference might be due to the extraction diluents used and the particular proportion of bio-ovicidal compounds present in each extract. In contrast, the mixed species extract MCM As-Nl was the most efficient on egg producing inhibition rates of embryonation and egg hatching of 84.83 and 87.04% respectively. The combination of the two extracts produced significantly higher effects as compared to those of each single plant species extract. It appears that, the mixture of extract has an additive effect. This effect could be due to the interaction of bioactive compounds present in the mixture. The compounds such as flavonoids, sterols, alkaloids, saponins, triterpens, tanins, polyphenols and anthraquinons were present in MCM As and MCM Nl except alkaloids in this later. These substances act specifically on the cell membrane of eggs and proteins (collagens) of larval cuticule, changing their permeability and reducing the cholesterol level in the egg membrane [14, 15, 18, 19]. This process favours the passage of secondary metabolites inside the cell where they interfere with the mechanism of cellular mitosis by inhibiting the segmentation of blastomers in the case of fresh eggs and paralyzing the larva present in eggs in the case of embryonated eggs .
The effect of MCM As was more visible on larvae as compared to the activity of mixed extracts while MCM Nl extract was less active. This later result was also obtained by Yondo  using Methylene Chloride-Methanol extract of Pseudospondias microcarpa on L1 and L2 larvae of H. bakeri. The different activities obtained were due to the synergistic effects of bio-larvicidal compounds present in the two above mentioned extracts. In fact, alkaloids are known to be more bio-larvicidal. This justifies the stronger effect of MCM As extract. On the other hand, these alkaloids were not found in MCM Nl extract, thus its low larvicidal activity. The effect of the mixture of extracts on larvae was slightly weaker than that of MCM As extract alone. This might be due to non competitive inhibition effect of MCM Nl  to the bioavailability of substances contained in the extract . The altered and swollen aspect of larvae cuticle after exposure to extract could be as a result of penetration of secondary metabolites through worm cuticle. After the penetration of bioactive substances in the cuticule, they can act on larvae in several ways. Firstly, they can prevent the absorption of glucose or block post synaptic receptors thus paralyzing the larvae . Secondly, they may also induce the release of gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA) which blocks the transmission of nerve impulses or decoupling the phosphorylation oxydative reaction which can lead to the exhortion of the energy of the larvae . Thirdly, they can link to free proteins available in the gastro-intestinal tract of larvae causing anorexia and finally the death of the worm thereafter [14, 26].
The medicinal plants are rich in secondary metabolites and among the vast array of bioactive compounds alkaloids, flavonoids, glycosides, saponins and terpenoids are in high interest. Of the several methods are available for separating plant constituents, the chromatographic procedure is the most commonly used techniques for general application. The present TLC studies confirmed the presence of active metabolites in the Methylene Chloride-Methanol (1:1) extracts of the study species, A. senegalensis and N. latifolia. The mobile phases used for TLC separated the bioactive compounds.
The Methylene Chloride-Methanol of A. senegalensis and N. latifolia extract mixture showed an additive ovicidal effect whereas Methylene Chloride-Methanol extract of A. senegalensis was more larvicidal. The extracts may be used as soil «disinfectants» and could contribute in the disruption of the life cycle of certain soil transmitted nematodes. This report confirmed the presence of the rich variety of bioactive compounds in the plant of the study and it leads for the development of the new pharmaceuticals that address hither to unmet therapeutic needs. However, further studies are needed to confirm their efficacy (in situ) and especially to investigate their potential toxic effects.
Inhibition rate of embryonation
Research Unit of Biology and Applied Ecology
- MCM As:
Methylene Chloride-Methanol extract of Annona senegalensis
- MCM As-Nl:
Methylene Chloride-Methanol mixture of extract of Annona senegalensis and Nauclea latifolia
- MCM Nl:
Methylene Chloride-Methanol extract of Nauclea latifolia
National Herbarium of Cameroon
Neglected Tropical Diseases
Wabo Pone J, Yondo J, Fossi Tankoua O, Komtangi MC, Bilong Bilong CF. Mpoame Mbida the in vitro effect of Chenopodium ambrosioides (Chenopodiaceae) extract on the parasitic nematode Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidae). J Pharm Phyto. 2011;3:1–5.
Etung kollins N, Wabo Pone J, Payne VK, Yondo J, Komtangi MC, Mpoame Mbida, Bilong Bilong, C. In vitro Comparative effect of aqueous (cold and hot water) and ethanolic extracts of the seeds of aframomum danielli (zingiberaceae) on three life cycle stages of the parasitic nematode Heligmosomoides Bakeri (Nematoda; Heligmosomatidae), parasite of the laboratory mice (Mus Musculus). Med Aromat Plants. 2012;1:111. doi: 10.4172/2167-0412.1000111.
Nandhini A, Sumathi C. An overview of herbals used in helminthosis. World J Pharm Res. 2014;3(10):350–62.
Hotez PJ, Molyneux DH, Fenwick A, Kumaresan J, Elrich Sachs S, Sachs JD, et al. Control of neglected diseases. New England J Med. 2007;357:1018–27.
WHO. Link between water and rehabilitation, health and hygiene: figure and accomplished facts. Geneva. 2004. http://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/publications/facts2004/en/.
Ngangout A, Wabo Pone J, Payne VK, Komtangi MC, Yondo J, Mbogning Tayo G, et al. Ovicidal and larvicidal activities of aqueous and ethanolic extract of stem bark of Annona senegalensis (Annonaceae) on Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidae). Asian Pac J of Trop Biomed. 2012:1–5.
Githiori JB. Evaluation of anthelmintic properties of ethno-veterinary plant preparation used as livestock dewormers by pastoralists and small holder farmers in kenya. Sweden: Doctoral dissertation, Department of Biomedical sciences and Verterinary Public Health, SLU Acta Universitatis Agricultural sulciae; 2004. p. 76.
D’Angelo F, Wabo Pone J, Komtangi M, Yondo J, Vittori S. Evaluation of the ovicidal and larvicidal activities of methylene chloride-methanol extracts of Annona senegalensis stem bark on Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidae). Glob J Sci Front Res. 2014;14(2):29–39.
Bizimenyera E, Githiori JB, Eloff J, Swan G. In vitro activity of Peltophorum africanum Sond. (Fabaceae) extracts on the egg hatching and larval development of the parasitic nematode Trichostrongylus colubriformis. Vet Parasitol. 2006; 142(3-4):336–43.
Hounzangbé-Adoté S, Attkapa E, Zinsou E, Hounkpe V, Hoste H. Antiparasitic effects of papaya seeds on gastro-intestinal strongles of small ruminants in south of Benin. Agronomic book of research of Benin; 2008. p. 13–7.
Wabo Pone J. Effects of Canthium mannii, Hiern, 1877 (Rubiaceae) extracts on two strongylid nematodes parasites: Ancylostoma caninum Ercolani, 1859 and Heligmosomoides polygyrus Dujardin, 1845. Thesis of Doctorate/Ph-d, Departement of Biology and Animal physiology, Faculty of Sciences, University of Yaounde I, Cameroon. 2007; 155p.
Mbogning Tayo G, Payne V, Wabo Pone J, Komtangi MC, Yondo J, Ngangout A, et al. In vitro ovicidal and larvicidal activities of aqueous and ethanolic extracts of the leaves of bidens pilosa (Asteraceae) on Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidae). Med Plants. 2012;4(3):121–5.
Camilla O, Carvalho Chagas S, Cotinguiba F, Furlan M, Brito G, Chaves M, et al. Anthelminthic effect of plant extracts on Haemonchus contortus and Strongyloides venezuelensis. Vet Parasitol. 2012;183(3–4):260–8. doi: 10.1016/j.vetpar.2011.07.05.
Kumar B, Tiwari P, Kumar M, Kaur M, Debnat J, Sharma P. Comparative anthelminthic activity of aqueous and ethanolic stem extract of Tinospora cordifolia. Int J Drug Dev Res. 2011;3:70–83.
Eguale T, Giday M. In vitro anthelminthic activity of crude extracts of five medicinal plants against egg hatching and larval development of Haemonchus contortus. J Ethnopharmacol. 2011;137:108–13.
Payne V, WaboPone J, Mbogning G, Komtangi MC, Yondo J, Ngangout A, et al. Ovicidal and larvicidal activity of aqueous and ethanolic extracts from Erythrina sigmoidea (Fabaceae) against Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidae). J of Biol and Chem Res. 2013;30(10):2319–3077.
Katiki L, Chagas A, Bizzo H, Ferreira J, Amarante A. Anthelminthic activity of Cymbopogon martinii, Cymbopogon schoenanthus and Mentha piperita essential oils evaluated in four different in vitro tests. Vet Parasitol. 2011;183:103–8.
Berkaloff A, Bourguet J, Favard P, Guinnebault M. Cellular biology and physiology. Paris: Hermann; 1975. p. 322.
Mervat A, Srour H. Saponins suppress nematode cholesterol biosynthesis and inhibit root knot nematode development in tomato seedlings. Nat Prod Chem Res. 2013;2(1):1–6.
Manolaraki, F. Anthelmintic properties of sainfoin (Onobrychis viciifoliae): Analysis of factors of variation and the function of phenotic compounds implicated. Paris: Thesis of Ph-D, speciality of pathology, toxicology, genetics and nutrition, National Institute Polytechnic of Toulouse (NIP); 2011. p. 185.
Yondo J. Anthelmintics and antioxydants properties of stem barck of Pseudospndias microcarpa Engl. 1877 (Anacardiaceae), Shumaniophyton magnificum Harms. 1897 (Rubiaceae) and Rouvolfia vomitaria Afzel. 1817 (Apocynaceae) aqueous and methylene-chloride methanol mixture extracts. Thesis of Ph-D, Animal Biology departement, Faculty of Sciences, Dschang University. 2014; 133p.
Amar M. Polyconsommation of psychotropes and principal interactions with associated pharmacologies. Permanent commitee of flight against toxicomanie (PCFT). Quebec. 2004; 184 p.
Himmelstjerna G, Coles G, Jackson F, Bauer C, Borgsteede F, Cirak V, et al. Standardization of the egg hatch test for the detection of benzimidazole resistance in parasitic nematodes. Parasitol Res. 2009;105:825–34.
Enriquez JB. Anthelminthic drugs used for the treatment of domesticated carnivors. Recueil de Méd Vét. 1993;189(5/6):499–512.
Chartier C, Itard I, Morel PC, Troncy PM. Manual of the tropica veterinary parasitology. Ed Tec et Doc. London. 2000;771 p.
Mali R, Wadeka R. Anthelmintic activity of Platycladus orientalis leaves extract. Indian J PharmSci. 2008;70:131–3.
We thank the traditional herbal traders of Noun- Cameroon M. Maxime Agbor who harvest the different stem barks of plants used in this work. The authors also thank the dotorate students of the Research Unit of Chemistry and Natural Substances for their help during extraction, phytochemical and TLC analysis of plant extracts.
The authors have not received any funding for this study.
Availability of data and materials
All data are incorporated in the paper.
Experimental protocols used in this study were approved by the Research Unit of Biology and Applied Ecology committee, Department of Animal Biology, University of Dschang, Cameroon.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Ngouateu Teufack, S.E., NMbogning Tayo, G., Ngangout Alidou, M. et al. Anthelminthic properties of Methylene chloride-methanol (1:1) extracts of two Cameroonians medicinal plants on Heligmosomoides bakeri (Nematoda: Heligmosomatidea). BMC Complement Altern Med 17, 400 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12906-017-1908-8
- Annona senegalensis
- Nauclea latifolia
- Heligmosomoides bakeri
- Additive effect