- Research article
- Open Access
Effect of electroacupuncture in postanesthetic shivering during regional anesthesia: a randomized controlled trial
BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine volume 12, Article number: 233 (2012)
Shivering during regional anesthesia is a common complication and is related to a decrease in the patient’s core body temperature. Previous studies have shown that acupuncture on specific acupoints can preserve core body temperature. The present study evaluated the effect of electroacupuncture in preventing the shivering caused by regional anesthesia.
This prospective and randomized controlled study analyzed the data from 80 patients undergoing urological surgery, who were classified as ASA I or II. Spinal anesthesia was performed in all patients using 15 mg of bupivacaine. The patients were randomly allocated to receive either placebo acupuncture (Group P, n = 40) or electroacupuncture (Group A, n = 40) for 30 min before administration of spinal anesthesia. Shivering score was recorded at 5 min intervals, with 0 representing no shivering and 4 representing the most severe shivering possible. Heart rate, blood pressure, and tympanic temperature were recorded before the intrathecal injection, and again every 5 min thereafter until 30 min.
After spinal anesthesia, the decrease in tympanic temperature was less for Group A patients than Group P, with the difference being statistically significant. After 15 min, 13 patients in Group P attained a shivering score of 3 or more, compared with 3 patients in Group A. Significantly more patients in Group P attained a shivering score of at least 1.
The prophylactic use of electroacupuncture might maintain core body temperature, and may effectively prevent the shivering that commonly develops during regional anesthesia.
Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry ACTRN12612000096853.
Regional anesthesia may impair a patient’s thermoregulatory control , with associated shivering being reported in up to 64% of cases [2–4]. Shivering during neuraxial anesthesia may potentially have a detrimental effect . Various opioid and non-opioid pharmacological treatments are used to manage postanesthetic shivering, but several side-effects have been reported for these agents, including hypotension, hypertension, sedation, respiratory depression, nausea, and vomiting [4, 6–9].
Acupuncture has been reported to exert a beneficial effect on postanesthetic nausea and vomiting . However, the effectiveness of acupuncture as a prophylactic modality against postanesthetic shivering had not been investigated. Regional anesthesia produces vasodilatation, which facilitates core-to-peripheral redistribution of heat and decreases the core body temperature . Several studies have reported that acupuncture exerts a thermoregulatory effect, but the mechanisms were not entirely understood [12, 13]. Acupuncture applied to a specific acupoint may induce slight core hyperthermia with a decrease in skin temperature, a finding which suggests that acupuncture might be able to reverse the core-to-periphery redistribution of heat .
Electroacupuncture rather than manual acupuncture has been used in many studies, because the parameters of electroacupuncture can be precisely controlled, allowing the study to be replicated . We hypothesized that electroacupuncture intervention might be able to prevent postanesthetic shivering. To test this hypothesis, we examined the effect of electroacupuncture treatment on postanesthetic shivering during regional anesthesia in patients undergoing ureteroendoscopic surgery.
The study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of Chang Gung Medical Foundation and Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry. Informed consent was obtained from every participant. A total of 85 patients of both sexes were prospectively included in the study. All patients were scheduled for elective ureteroendoscopy (URS) surgical procedures under spinal anesthesia between June 2010 and May 2011. We excluded from the study patients who had previously received acupuncture; or who had a history of hypo- or hyperthyroidism, cardiopulmonary disease, or psychological disorder; or who needed blood transfusion during surgery; or whose initial body temperature was >38.0°C or <36.0°C; or who had a known history of alcohol or substance abuse; or who were receiving vasodilators, or medications likely to alter thermoregulation; or who had received an ASA (American Society of Anesthesiologists) classification equal to or greater than 3; or who were younger than 20 years or older than 80 years.
All participants were randomly assigned to either Group A (electroacupuncture) or Group P (placebo) on the basis of a concealed allocation approach. A computerized random number table was used to determine the allocation to groups, with numbered opaque sealed envelopes containing the randomization schedule, and no restrictions on the randomization. The envelopes were kept by an investigator who was not an assessor of the study. The envelopes were opened immediately before the electroacupuncture treatment and acupuncturists were informed by messages sent by the investigator. Two groups of health care personnel participated in the study. The sealed envelopes were accessible only to the first group, consisting of acupuncturists who were to perform the electroacupuncture. The second group, namely anesthetists who were to perform spinal anesthesia, were blinded to the electroacupuncture allocation. All patients were also blinded to their allocation. Data were collected by nursing staff who were unaware that an electroacupuncture study was being conducted.
Electroacupuncture and placebo settings
Half of the patients in our overall sample were allocated to receive placebo acupuncture intervention (Group P, n = 40), and the other half received active electroacupuncture intervention (Group A, n = 40). All patients received the treatment or placebo treatment for 30 min before spinal anesthesia was administered. Two Taiwan-trained and licensed acupuncturists with a median of 4 years of experience provided study treatment in operating room at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Linkou. Group A patients received acupuncture at the ST36 (Zusanli) and ST37 (Shangjuxu) points bilaterally, with electrical stimulation, for 30 min before anesthesia. 30 G 3.8 cm long unused sterile needles were used for the study (YU KUANG, TAIWAN). Needles were inserted vertically to a depth not exceeding 1.3 cm. As the appropriate depth was reached, the acupuncturist did not manipulate the needles with twirling or lifting-inserting actions, but simply waited for de qi, which is the state of connection between the needle and the patient’s energetic flow. An electrostimulator, NihonRiko TOKKI MODEL III (NihonRiko Medical Co., Ltd., Nagasaki, Japan) was connected to the needles with a current of 1 mA and a frequency of 3 Hz. At this current intensity, patients typically feel a slight but not uncomfortable twitching. Electroacupuncture was applied for 30 min.
The control intervention (Group P) consisted of needling at non-channel points, with sham electrostimulation. For control patients, the procedures imitated those used for the active electroacupuncture intervention, but 1) needles were inserted at 4 points remote from any classically described meridian or extraordinary acupoint; and 2) no current was applied to the needles. The 4 points were located 3 cm lateral to the ST36 and ST37 points, respectively, bilaterally. The needles were inserted obliquely to a depth of approximately 1 cm, which was the minimum needed to allow a stable connection to the electroacupuncture leads. We used a control electrostimulator identical to the one that provided the electroacupuncture intervention, with the lead modified to prevent administration of electrical stimulation when the stimulator was turned on .
Surgical environment during anesthesia
The temperature of the operating room was maintained at 24°C. Two liters of irrigation fluid were used during each operation. The irrigation and intravenous fluids were preheated to 37°C in a warmed cabinet, and administered without in-line warming. No other warming device was used. Each patient was covered with one layer of surgical drapes and one layer of a cotton blanket, positioned over the thighs and calves. In addition, one layer of a cotton blanket was placed over the chest and arms. Before the spinal anesthesia procedure, each patient received 10 ml/kg lactated Ringer’s solution. Subarachnoid anesthesia was instituted at the interspace of either L3/4 or L4/5. Hyperbaric bupivacaine (5 mg/ml, 15 mg) was injected using a 25 G Quincke spinal needle (B. Braun Melsungen AG, Melsungen, Germany).
Measurement of blood pressure, heart rate, O2 saturation, and level of sensory block
Patients did not receive premedication. Their heart rate, blood pressure, and pulse oximetry arterial O2 saturation were recorded using standard non-invasive monitors before the intrathecal injection. Thereafter the same measurements were taken at 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 min respectively. During the perioperative period, sensory block was assessed with a pinprick test at 5 min intervals.
Measurement of core body temperature
Before the intrathecal injection, and thereafter at each 5 min interval during the perioperative period, the patient’s core body temperature was monitored by assessing tympanic temperature. We used an infrared noncontact ear thermometer (Chang Gung Medical Technology Co., Ltd., Taipei, Taiwan) for this measurement.
Evaluation of postanesthetic shivering
The presence and degree of shivering was recorded by an observer blinded to the study. Shivering was graded using a scale similar to that validated by Tsai and Chu , namely 0 = no shivering; 1 = piloerection or peripheral vasoconstriction, but no visible shivering; 2 = muscular activity in only one muscle group; 3 = muscular activity in more than one muscle group, but not generalized; and 4 = shivering involving the whole body. During surgery the patient’s shivering score was recorded at 5 min intervals. After the first 15 min, if a score of 3 or 4 was noted then the prophylaxis was regarded as having been ineffective, and 25 mg of intravenous meperidine was administered.
Rescue method and side effects
Side effects such as hypotension, nausea, vomiting, and hallucinations were recorded. Hypotension was defined as a decrease in mean blood pressure of more than 20% from baseline; baseline mean blood pressure had been measured in the ward before surgery. This was treated by crystalloid infusion, and if necessary, 5 mg ephedrine was administered intravenously. The amount of ephedrine given in each case was recorded. If patients developed nausea or vomiting, 10 mg intravenous metoclopramide was administered. Hallucination as a side effect was defined as a false sensory experience where a patient reported seeing, hearing, smelling, tasting, or feeling something that was nonexistent.
The attending anesthetists also assessed the degree of sedation on a 5-point scale: 1 = fully awake and oriented; 2 = drowsy; 3 = eyes closed but rousable on command; 4 = eyes closed but rousable to mild physical stimulation; and 5 = eyes closed and unrousable to mild physical stimulation .
The sample size was calculated using PASS 2008 software. We chose 15 cases in electroacupuncture group and 15 cases in control group for the pilot study. The timepoint for evaluation of poanesthetic shivering is 15 min after spinal anesthesia. The shivering rate is 60% in control group and 27% in electroacupuncture group. This number of cases per group would suggest an approximately 33% improvement in postanesthetic shivering. Consequently, a power calculation (α = 0.05 and β = 0.2) indicated that each group should include at least 35 patients. The SPSS program (v 17) was used to analyze the statistical data (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). All plots were performed by R 2.13.0 software.
Categorical variables were compared between the groups using the Chi-squared test and Fisher exact test, if the cases numbered fewer than 5 patients. Between-group data for continuous variables were analyzed using the t-test for 2 independent samples. The incidence of shivering and side-effects were compared using the Chi-square test and Fisher exact test, if the cases numbered fewer than 5 patients. The results were reported as mean (standard deviation). A P-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
Eighty-five patients were enrolled for the study. One patient was excluded because of psychological disorder and 4 patients were excluded because of cardiopulmonary disease. The Consort flow diagram for the study is shown in Figure 1. Patient characteristics including sex, duration of surgery, and the median level of sensory block were similar among the groups (Table 1).
Hemodynamic changes and side effects
The sedation score was 1 in all patients just after intrathecal injection. No differences were observed between the groups for hemodynamic values (Figures 2 and 3). However, within-group differences were found for the comparison of preoperative and postoperative hemodynamic values (Figures 2 and 3). Hypotension developed in 12 patients in Group A and in 8 patients in Group P, but the difference between groups was not significant (Table 2). In all these patients, hypotension was successfully controlled by the administration of crystalloid infusion and 5 mg ephedrine. All hemodynamic measurements obtained after 30 min were stable, and we did not perform comparative analysis of these data. The incidence of nausea and vomiting did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (Table 2).
Core body temperature
The mean core temperature post-anesthesia compared with at baseline differed significantly between the 2 groups. The core temperature was significantly higher in Group A compared with Group P (P < 0.001) (Figure 4).
As Table 3 shows, 23 of 40 patients in Group P experienced shivering. This proportion was significantly higher than that found in Group A (13/40) (P = 0.03). Further analysis showed that in Group P, 10 of 40 patients experienced shivering at grade 4, whereas only 1 patient in Group A (1/40) experienced such severe shivering (Table 4). The difference between groups was statistically significant (P = 0.003).
For both groups combined, 20% of patients (16/80) experienced grade 3 or 4 shivering and requested treatment; these patients were administered 25 mg meperidine intravenously. After one such dose, shivering ceased in all patients.
Two main mechanisms of postanesthetic shivering are hypothermia and recalibration of the temperature setpoint to a higher level [1, 18, 19]. The management of postanesthetic shivering must focus on correcting these pathophysiologic changes [20–22], as preserving the patient’s body heat is an important issue. Butwick et al.  used a warming device to preserve body heat, and other physicians [9, 20, 21, 24, 25] have used drugs to constrict the blood vessels, thus preserving body heat.
The effect of drugs in preventing postanesthetic shivering has previously been investigated and compared [9, 24, 25]. To the best of our knowledge, ours was the first study to examine the application of electroacupuncture to prevent postanesthetic shivering during regional anesthesia. Our results (Table 3) showed that electroacupuncture exerted a significant antishivering effect compared with the placebo treatment. Furthermore, severe shivering (grade 4) was significantly lower in Group A than Group P (Table 4).
Lin et al.  proposed that stimulating acupoint ST36 may produce a slight increase in oral temperature, with a simultaneous decrease in the cutaneous temperature of the limbs (measurement limited to certain skin locations). The same researchers extended their study to record additional skin locations, and the results indicated that stimulation of ST36 on the left leg produced vasoconstriction in both legs, but not in either arm . Reasons for the discrepant findings between the 2 studies were uncertain but may have included different needling depths (0.5 to 1.3 cun versus 0.5 to 2.3 cun). Dyrehag et al.  found that skin temperature tended to decrease after 30 min of electroacupuncture stimulation. This evidence supports the hypothesis that acupuncture to ST36 may lead to peripheral vasoconstriction.
In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), ST36 is a Xiahe and He point of the stomach meridian of Foot-Yangming, and ST37 is a Xiahe point of the large intestine meridian. Clinical observation has shown that performing acupuncture on ST36 produces a clearer shape in the radial pulse. This finding may mean that the borders of the radial pulse emerge, which TCM physicians are able to detect by manipulation of the radial pulse through pushing or other movements. We speculated that this phenomenon may be attributed to peripheral vasoconstriction. We also hypothesized that acupuncture to ST36 may facilitate the preservation of heat. In addition, the Dao Ma needling technique, which is characterized by penetrating 2 to 3 adjacent acupuncture points simultaneously, is widely employed by Tung-style acupuncturists to enhance the therapeutic effect . Based on these reasons, we chose the 2 acupuncture points of ST36 and ST37 for pretreatment of postanesthetic shivering.
Our results suggested that electroacupuncture to ST36 and ST37 could preserve core body temperature during regional anesthesia. According to our data, the mean tympanic temperature of patients increased slightly after 30 min of electroacupuncture treatment (before administration of spinal anesthesia), compared with baseline. In both the treatment and placebo groups, mean core temperature then gradually declined after anesthesia. However, this drop in temperature differed significantly between the 2 groups. The mean core temperature remained higher in Group A compared with Group P at the same time point (Figure 4).
Our findings indicated that acupuncture to ST36 and ST37 did not prevent bradycardia or hypotension after spinal anesthesia. The rate of bradycardia and hypotension (defined as a decrease in mean blood pressure of more than 20% from baseline) within 30 min after anesthesia did not differ significantly between groups. We also found no significant difference between the 2 groups for postanesthetic heart rate and mean blood pressure; in both groups, these 2 measurements declined step by step in a similar pattern. This result was similar to those of previous studies of drugs to prevent shivering [9, 20, 24, 25]. The rate of nausea and vomiting, and of hallucination, did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (Table 2).
Previous studies have demonstrated that preoperative electroacupuncture on bilateral ST36 (Zusanli) acupoints with low and high frequency both can postpone time for the first dose of pethidine after operation and decrease the PCA demands and total morphine delivered in patients undergoing lower abdominal surgery . Patients enrolled into the study underwent ureteroendoscopy, which is not major abdominal surgery, and suffered almost no pain in the operative room or postanesthetic room. There was no analgesic requirement for these patients. In view of this, it remains unknown whether electroacupuncture has led to pain-related phenomenon and side effects in our current study.
Previous studies have also shown that low frequency electroacupuncture at acupoints of lower extremities attenuates sympathetic nerve activity, which may mediate muscle shivering for heat production . In this regard, low frequency electroacupuncture was selected as the treatment modality in the present study. In our pilot study setting, we adjusted the electric current based on the conception of patients. Current was tuned up to an amplitude that patient felt little but acceptable twitching, and then was tuned back to an amplitude that patient almost did not feel any twitching. We found that most patients did not feel any twitching with a current of 1 mA.
Preservation of core body temperature is essential to prevent postanesthetic shivering, and electroacupuncture to ST36 and ST37 might achieve this objective. Although the precise mechanism is not yet clearly understood, electroacupuncture may work as a treatment modality for patients who experience shivering related to spinal anesthesia.
American Society of Anesthesiologists
- Group P:
- Group A:
Ozaki M, Kurz A, Sessler DI, Lenhardt R, Schroeder M, Moayeri A, Noyes KM, Rotheneder E: Thermoregulatory thresholds during epidural and spinal anesthesia. Anesthesiology. 1994, 81: 282-288. 10.1097/00000542-199408000-00004.
Chan AM, Ng KF, Tong EW, Jan GS: Control of shivering under regional anesthesia in obstetric patients with tramadol. Can J Anaesth. 1999, 46: 253-258. 10.1007/BF03012605.
Sessler DI, Ponte J: Shivering during epidural anesthesia. Anesthesiology. 1990, 72: 816-821. 10.1097/00000542-199005000-00008.
Jeon YT, Jeon YS, Kim YC, Bahk JH, Do SH, Lim YJ: Intrathecal clonidine does not reduce post-spinal shivering. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2005, 49: 1509-1513. 10.1111/j.1399-6576.2005.00783.x.
Alfonsi P: Postanaesthetic shivering: epidemiology, pathophysiology, and approaches to prevention and management. Drugs. 2001, 61: 2193-2205. 10.2165/00003495-200161150-00004.
Kranke P, Eberhart LH, Roewer N, Tramer MR: Pharmacological treatment of postoperative shivering: a quantitative systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Anesth Analg. 2002, 94: 453-460.
Kranke P, Eberhart LH, Roewer N, Tramer MR: Single-dose parenteral pharmacological interventions for the prevention of postoperative shivering: a quantitative systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Anesth Analg. 2004, 99: 718-727. 10.1213/01.ANE.0000130589.00098.CD.
Terasako K, Yamamoto M: Comparison between pentazocine, pethidine and placebo in the treatment of post-anesthetic shivering. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2000, 44: 311-312. 10.1034/j.1399-6576.2000.440316.x.
Sagir O, Gulhas N, Toprak H, Yucel A, Begec Z, Ersoy O: Control of shivering during regional anaesthesia: prophylactic ketamine and granisetron. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand. 2007, 51: 44-49. 10.1111/j.1399-6576.2006.01196.x.
Fan CF, Tanhui E, Joshi S, Trivedi S, Hong Y, Shevde K: Acupressure treatment for prevention of postoperative nausea and vomiting. Anesth Analg. 1997, 84: 821-825.
Crowley LJ, Buggy DJ: Shivering and neuraxial anesthesia. Reg Anesth Pain Med. 2008, 33: 241-252.
Lin MT, Chandra A, Chen-Yen SM, Chern YF: Needle stimulation of acupuncture loci Chu-Chih (LI-11) and Ho-Ku (LI-4) induces hypothermia effects and analgesia in normal adults. Am J Chin Med. 1981, 9: 74-83. 10.1142/S0192415X8100010X.
Lin MT, Chandra A, Chen-Yen SM: Effects of needle stimulation of acupuncture loci Nei-Kuan (EH-6), Tsu-San-Li (St-36), San-Yin-Chiao (Sp-6) and Chu-Chih (LI-11) on cutaneous temperature and pain threshold in normal adults. Am J Chin Med. 1981, 9: 305-314. 10.1142/S0192415X81000408.
Zhou W, Longhurst JC: Neuroendocrine mechanisms of acupuncture in the treatment of hypertension. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2012, 2012: 878673-
Andreescu C, Glick RM, Emeremni CA, Houck PR, Mulsant BH: Acupuncture for the treatment of major depressive disorder: a randomized controlled trial. J Clin Psychiatry. 2011, 72: 1129-1135. 10.4088/JCP.10m06105.
Tsai YC, Chu KS: A comparison of tramadol, amitriptyline, and meperidine for postepidural anesthetic shivering in parturients. Anesth Analg. 2001, 93: 1288-1292. 10.1097/00000539-200111000-00052.
Wilson E, David A, MacKenzie N, Grant IS: Sedation during spinal anaesthesia: comparison of propofol and midazolam. Br J Anaesth. 1990, 64: 48-52. 10.1093/bja/64.1.48.
Sessler DI, Rubinstein EH, Moayeri A: Physiologic responses to mild perianesthetic hypothermia in humans. Anesthesiology. 1991, 75: 594-610. 10.1097/00000542-199110000-00009.
Buggy DJ, Crossley AW: Thermoregulation, mild perioperative hypothermia and postanaesthetic shivering. Br J Anaesth. 2000, 84: 615-628. 10.1093/bja/84.5.615.
Norouzi M, Doroodian MR, Salajegheh S: Optimum dose of ketamine for prevention of postanesthetic shivering; a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial. Acta Anaesthesiol Belg. 2011, 62: 33-36.
Piper SN, Rohm KD, Maleck WH, Fent MT, Suttner SW, Boldt J: Dolasetron for preventing postanesthetic shivering. Anesth Analg. 2002, 94: 106-111.
Miyawaki T, Yao H, Koyama E, Maeda S: Prevention of postanesthetic shivering with intravenous administration of aspirin. J Anesth. 1991, 5: 123-127. 10.1007/s0054010050123.
Butwick AJ, Lipman SS, Carvalho B: Intraoperative forced air-warming during cesarean delivery under spinal anesthesia does not prevent maternal hypothermia. Anesth Analg. 2007, 105: 1413-1419. 10.1213/01.ane.0000286167.96410.27.
Mohta M, Kumari N, Tyagi A, Sethi AK, Agarwal D, Singh M: Tramadol for prevention of postanaesthetic shivering: a randomised double-blind comparison with pethidine. Anaesthesia. 2009, 64: 141-146. 10.1111/j.1365-2044.2008.05711.x.
Honarmand A, Safavi MR: Comparison of prophylactic use of midazolam, ketamine, and ketamine plus midazolam for prevention of shivering during regional anaesthesia: a randomized double-blind placebo controlled trial. Br J Anaesth. 2008, 101: 557-562. 10.1093/bja/aen205.
Lin MT, Liu GG, Soong JJ, Chern YF, Wu KM: Effects of stimulation of acupuncture loci Ta-Chuei (Go-14), Nei-Kuan (EH-6) and Tsu-San-Li (St-36) on thermoregulatory function of normal adults. Am J Chin Med. 1979, 7: 324-332. 10.1142/S0192415X79000295.
Dyrehag LE, Widerstrom-Noga EG, Carlsson SG, Andersson SA: Effects of repeated sensory stimulation sessions (electro-acupuncture) on skin temperature in chronic pain patients. Scand J Rehabil Med. 1997, 29: 243-250.
Maher JH: Advanced Tung Style Acupuncture. 2005, RBC
Lin JG, Lo MW, Wen YR, Hsieh CL, Tsai SK, Sun WZ: The effect of high and low frequency electroacupuncture in pain after lower abdominal surgery. Pain. 2002, 9: 509-514.
Stener-Victorin E, Jedel E, Janson PO, Sverrisdottir YB: Low-frequency electroacupuncture and physical exercise decrease high muscle sympathetic nerve activity in polycystic ovary syndrome. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol. 2009, 297: R387-R395. 10.1152/ajpregu.00197.2009.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6882/12/233/prepub
The authors are grateful for the invaluable help provided by the operating room and postanesthetic room nurses at the Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, Taoyuan, Taiwan to allow completion of the study.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
YCH and BYY designed the study protocol, drafted the manuscript and participated in the study as a coordinator. BYY participated in the study design and conducted the acupuncture treatment. CJC conducted statistical analysis. JYH, ITS, WJZ, YFT and HPY participated in the study design, drafted and reviewed the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Bo-Yan Yeh, Yi-Chun Hsu contributed equally to this work.
About this article
Cite this article
Yeh, BY., Hsu, YC., Huang, JY. et al. Effect of electroacupuncture in postanesthetic shivering during regional anesthesia: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Complement Altern Med 12, 233 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1186/1472-6882-12-233