Criteria (PICOS) | Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
---|---|---|
Participants | (1) Study participants are at least 18 years old; (2) Major depressive disorder patients are included at least one of the following requirements: â‘ Diagnosed by the clinical doctor; â‘¡Study participants must meet the inclusion criteria for major depressive disorder patients based on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th/5th Edition (DSM-4/DSM-5) or the International Statistical Classification of Diseases 10th/11th Revision (ICD-10/ICD-11). | Participants who have psychiatric or physical diseases except for major depressive disorder. |
Interventions | Interventions must be presented in detail and involve both meditation/mindfulness and yoga components: (1) Each Intervention must have the same parts and encompass; meditation/mindfulness, asanas (yoga posture), and pranayama (yoga breathing techniques); (2) Yoga is the main intervention that its movement component (physical activity); (3) Duration and frequency of the practice do not affect the Intervention’s eligibility; (4) All forms of intervention are included, like online/DVD/offline, etc. | Interventions may mention mindfulness or meditation practices, but the primary components, such as laughter yoga, are not mindfulness or meditation elements. |
Comparison | There is no limitation on the comparator arm. It can be any other intervention type, like other psychological and physical interventions/waitlist controls/usual treatment, etc. | N/A |
Outcomes | (1) Studies include at least one measurement of depression, anxiety, rumination; (2) All of them were measured by validated self-reported or clinician-administered scales (For example, Depression can be measured by the Beck Depression Inventory or the Hamilton Rating Scale; Anxiety can be measured by the Hamilton Anxiety Scale; Rumination can be measured by the Ruminative Responses Scale). | N/A |
Study design | Only randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in English or Chinese were eligible. | (1) Duplicated studies; (2) Full text cannot be reached; (3) No data or not clear reported for analysis; (4) Unpublished literature; (5) Studies lacking comparison group; (6) RCTs registries or ongoing studies. |
Setting | There were no restrictions on places. It could take place in any other places like hospitals, centers, homes, etc. | N/A |