Skip to main content

Table 4 Capability of M. communis EO and its main components to inhibit the biofilm metabolic activity

From: Chemical composition, antibiofilm, cytotoxic, and anti-acetylcholinesterase activities of Myrtus communis L. leaves essential oil

Time

Myrtle EO (mg/ml)

Myrtenyl acetate (mg/ml)

1,8-Cineole (mg/ml)

α-Pinene (mg/ml)

Linalool (mg/ml)

0

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

EC

21.49

(± 0.57)

27.15

(± 1.33)

37.59

(± 0.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

61.34

(± 1.67)****

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0.0)

0

(± 0)

6.19

(± 0.15)

33.75

(± 1.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

56.72

(± 1.67)****

LM

6.81

(± 0.57)

38.74

(± 0.57)

68.06

(1.57)

20.05

(± 2.05)****

39.25

(± 3.32)

41.73

(± 2.05)

0

(± 0)

39.62

(± 4.56)

55.17

(± 1.33)

27.72

(± 1.67)****

29.83

(± 0.57)

67.71

(± 2.33)

33.42

(± 1.67)****

43.42

(± 0.57)

54.47

(± 3.67)

PC

23.56

(± 1.33)

57.93

(± 1.67)

60.82

(± 1.67)

46.18

(± 1.07)****

59.10

(± 2.33)

60.77

(± 2.57)

20.38

(± 2.33)

30.44

(± 4.21)

35.65

(± 2.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

36.81

(± 1.67)

0

(± 0)

62.31

(± 3.33)

77.84

(± 2.67)****

PA

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

50.19

(± 1.57)

95.12

(± 1.33)****

95.72

(± 0.57)****

96.99

(± 0.57)****

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

31.32

(± 1.67)****

40.22

(± 1.33)

30.12

(± 1.33)****

48.54

(± 2.57) ****

59.59

(± 3.33) ***

SA

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

50.29

(± 1.67)****

78.13

(± 1.67)****

0

(± 0)

5.76

(± 0.57)*

12.03

(± 0.57)***

76.23

(± 1.67)****

78.07

(± 1.67)****

89.41

(± 1.67)****

0

(± 0)

72.34

(± 3.56)****

77.05

(± 4.87)****

24 h

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

EC

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

6.36

(± 1.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

32.29

(± 1.67)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0.0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

16.62

(± 1.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

LM

24.44

(± 1.57)

61.65

(± 2.67)

68.65

(± 1.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

50.89

(± 2.67)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

2.59

(± 1.67)

22.56

(± 1.67)

42.80

(± 2.25)

43.73

(± 2.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

PC

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

64.11

(± 1.67)

36.28

(± 1.67)

52.70

(± 2.25)

68.70

(± 2.25)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

35.75

(± 1.25)

63.27

(± 1.67)

71.59

(± 1.67)

27.86

(± 0)

45.04

(± 4.34)

45.20

(± 2.34)

PA

13.43

(± 1.67)

32.86

(± 2.24)

45.44

(± 1.57)

37.77

(± 1.73)

53.62

(± 1.57)

70.79

(± 1.67)

9.65

(± 0.15)

20.35

(± 0.65)

52.79

(± 2.21)

11.21

(± 0.86)

30.31

(± 1.57)

65.31

(± 1.67)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

38.10

(± 0.57)

SA

31.86

(± 1.67)

51.10

(± 1.45)

65.30

(± 2.25)

34.52

(± 0.57)

63.39

(± 1.67)

69.77

(± 1.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

11.33

(± 1.33)

26.77

(± 2.67)

35.88

(± 1.57)

17.98

(± 0)

37.44

(± 1.57)

44.92

(± 3.67)

48 h

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

0.4

1

2

EC

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

26.53

(± 1.67)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

31.08

(± 0.0)

3.44

(± 0)

10.23

(± 0.15)

45.84

(± 1.33)

0

(± 0)

5.14

(± 0)

8.77

(± 0.57)

LM

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

60.63

(1.57)

17.74

(± 2.06)

39.17

(± 3.32)

49.97

(± 2.05)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

53.92

(± 1.33)

25.67

(± 1.67)

45.49

(± 0.57)

61.83

(± 2.33)

0

(± 0)

4.19

(± 0.57)

55.51

(± 3.67)

PC

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

4.09

(± 2.33)

14.07

(± 4.21)

38.28

(± 2.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 3.33)

24.18

(± 1.67)

PA

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

23.04

(± 1.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

15.73

(± 0.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

43.89

(± 0)

20.56

(± 0)

40.30

(± 1.67)

40.71

(± 1.33)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

14.51

(± 1.13)

SA

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

44.96

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

7.37

(± 0.57)

12.44

(± 0)

31.36

(± 0.57)*

32.19

(± 0.57)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

32.19

(± 1.21)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

0

(± 0)

  1. The test was performed with 0.4, 1 and 2 mg/ml that were added at time zero, on 24 h-biofilms and on 48 h-biofilms, using the MTT assay. Results are reported as percent of inhibition respect to the control (for which the inhibition was assumed = 0). Results are the mean of three experiments (± SD). EC: E. coli; LM: L. monocytogenes; PC: P. carotovorum; PA: P. aeruginosa; SA: S. aureus. * p < 0.05;*** p < 0.001; ****p < 0.0001 compared with values obtained with EO (ANOVA followed by Dunnett’s multiple comparisontest)