Author (Ref.) | Diagnostic criteria | Sample size | Age range, mean (years) | Sex (Male/female) | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Trial group | Control group | Trial group | Control group | Trial group | Control group | ||
Hu (2001) [32] | Clinical diagnosis and negative investigations | 49 | 36 | 18–70, 43.5 | 19.5–69, 42.5 | 19/30 | 14/22 |
Cao (2008) [33] | Clinical diagnosis | 49 | 36 | 18–70, 43.5 | 19–69, 42.5 | 19/30 | 14/22 |
Li (2008) [34] | Rome II criteria, TCM diagnostic criteria and negative investigations | 45 | 45 | 23–68, 39.7 | 21–65, 43.4 | 12/33 | 15/30 |
Deng and Su (2010)a [31] | Rome III criteria | 142 | 142 | 19–73, 45.8 | 19–69, 44.9 | 50/92 | 53/89 |
Deng and Su (2010)b [31] | Rome III criteria | 140 | 142 | 18–75, 46.7 | 19–69, 44.9 | 51/89 | 53/89 |
Mu, (2012) [35] | Rome III criteria and negative investigations | 63 | 62 | 18–60, 34.0 | 18–60, 35.0 | 28/35 | 29/33 |
Zhang, (2013) [36] | Rome III criteria and negative investigations | 60 | 60 | NM, 51.5 | NM, 52.8 | 32/28 | 35/25 |
Lv, (2014) [37] | Rome III criteria, TCM diagnostic criteria and negative investigations | 41 | 20 | 20–68, 47.2 | 20–68, 45.5 | 17/24 | 9/11 |
Zhang, (2014) [38] | Rome III criteria, TCM diagnostic criteria and negative investigations | 29 | 28 | 29–63, 50.1 | 25–64, 47.4 | 14/15 | 14/14 |
Lan and Yuan, (2016) [39] | Clinical diagnosis | 33 | 33 | 22–69, 50.5 | 21–69, 49.2 | 18/15 | 17/16 |
Liu et al., (2016) [40] | Rome III criteria, TCM diagnostic criteria and negative investigations | 30 | 30 | NM, 45.8 | NM, 44.2 | 13/17 | 14/16 |
Li, (2016) [41] | Rome III criteria | 34 | 34 | 18–59, 37.2 | 22–58, 37.6 | 15/19 | 16/18 |