Skip to main content

Table 2 Overall Recommendations for Use of Appraised Guidelines

From: Complementary and alternative medicine recommendations for depression: a systematic review and assessment of clinical practice guidelines

  Overall Guideline CAM Section
Guideline Appraiser 1 Appraiser 2 Appraiser 1 Appraiser 2
Piotrowski 2017 [52] No No No No
Parikh 2016 [53] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Ravindran 2016 [54] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Oslin 2016 [55] Yes with modifications Yes Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Jobst 2016 [56] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications No No
Trangle 2016 [57] Yes with modifications Yes Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Zhao 2015 [58] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Cleare 2015 [59] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications No Yes with modifications
Bauer 2015 [60] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications No No
Álvarez-Ariza 2014 [61] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Bauer 2013 [62] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Schwenk 2011 [63] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications No No
Gelenberg 2010 [64] Yes with modifications Yes Yes with modifications No
NCCMH 2010 [65] Yes Yes Yes Yes
Henderson 2010 [66] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications Yes with modifications
Malhi 2009 [67] Yes with modifications Yes with modifications No No