Peer Review reports
| Original Submission | ||
|---|---|---|
| 10 Sep 2018 | Submitted | Original manuscript |
| 17 Sep 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Sajjad Ahmad |
| 21 Sep 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Haroon Badshah |
| 26 Oct 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Congtao Yu |
| Resubmission - Version 2 | ||
| 26 Oct 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 2 |
| 12 Nov 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Sajjad Ahmad |
| 13 Nov 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Haroon Badshah |
| 22 Nov 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Congtao Yu |
| Resubmission - Version 3 | ||
| 22 Nov 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 3 |
| 4 Dec 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Sajjad Ahmad |
| 5 Dec 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Haroon Badshah |
| 7 Dec 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Congtao Yu |
| Resubmission - Version 4 | ||
| 7 Dec 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 4 |
| 29 Dec 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Sajjad Ahmad |
| 3 Jan 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Ismail Shah |
| 8 Jan 2019 | Author responded | Author comments - Congtao Yu |
| Resubmission - Version 5 | ||
| 8 Jan 2019 | Submitted | Manuscript version 5 |
| Publishing | ||
| 10 Jan 2019 | Editorially accepted | |
| 31 Jan 2019 | Article published | 10.1186/s12906-019-2435-6 |
You can find further information about peer review here.