Skip to main content

Table 4 Scaled domain percentages for appraisers of each guideline

From: Headache and migraine clinical practice guidelines: a systematic review and assessment of complementary and alternative medicine recommendations

Guideline Domain score (%)
Scope and Purpose Stakeholder Involvement Rigour of Development Clarity of Presentation Applicability Editorial Independence
Ren 2020 [28] Overall Guideline 94.4 77.8 54.2 69.4 37.5 37.5
CAM Section 94.4 77.8 54.2 69.4 37.5 37.5
Araki 2019 [29] Overall Guideline 66.7 36.1 41.7 88.9 18.8 29.2
CAM Section 75.0 16.7 44.8 66.7 18.8 29.2
Al Khaled 2017 [32] Overall Guideline 91.7 61.1 44.8 94.4 14.6 58.3
CAM Section 91.7 36.1 38.5 72.2 6.3 58.3
Moisset 2016 [34] Overall Guideline 97.2 61.1 32.3 80.6 12.5 45.8
CAM Section 91.7 44.4 27.1 61.1 4.2 45.8
Robbins 2016 [35] Overall Guideline 80.6 36.1 79.2 91.7 14.6 100.0
CAM Section 80.6 27.8 68.8 75.0 10.4 100.0
Becker 2015 [36] Overall Guideline 83.3 77.8 47.9 83.3 39.6 87.5
CAM Section 80.6 52.8 40.6 63.9 31.3 87.5
Bendtsen 2012 [38] Overall Guideline 94.4 44.4 13.5 75.0 27.1 41.7
CAM Section 80.6 33.3 9.4 50.0 16.7 41.7
Holland 2012 [39] Overall Guideline 83.3 22.2 65.6 66.7 8.3 95.8
CAM Section 83.3 13.9 60.4 66.7 6.3 95.8
NICE 2012 [40] Overall Guideline 100.0 83.3 91.7 97.2 72.9 75.0
CAM Section 100.0 66.7 85.4 97.2 68.8 75.0
Pringsheim 2012 [41] Overall Guideline 94.4 86.1 86.5 100.0 70.8 87.5
CAM Section 94.4 47.2 79.2 100.0 54.2 87.5
Sarchielli 2012 [43] Overall Guideline 63.9 30.6 49.0 91.7 6.3 16.7
CAM Section 61.1 19.4 42.7 77.8 2.1 16.7
Vukovic 2012 [44] Overall Guideline 91.7 44.4 25.0 86.1 25.0 0.0
CAM Section 88.9 30.6 22.9 80.6 10.4 0.0
Bryans 2011 [45] Overall Guideline 86.1 50.0 63.5 88.9 6.3 75.0
CAM Section 86.1 41.7 62.5 91.7 0.0 75.0