Skip to main content

Table 3 Sensitivity analyses according to various moderators

From: Quality of life in cancer patients treated with mistletoe: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Moderator

N studies

Effect Sizes SMDa

95% CIs

Heterogeneity I2

z-score

p value < =b

Risk of Bias status

 High

22

0.66

0.41–0.90

75.5

5.2

0.001

 Low

1

0.84

0.62–1.1

0

7.4

0.001

 Some

7

0.56

0.12–1.0

93.7

2.5

0.014

Blinding

 Yes

3

0.96

0.30–1.62

77.4

2.9

0.041

 No

27

0.61

0.39–0.82

85.3

5.4

0.001

Randomized

 Yes

25

0.70

0.47–0.93

86.3

6.0

0.001

 No

5

0.38

−0.09-0.85

63.4

1.58

0.11

Additional Treatment

 Chemotherapy

7

0.41

0.05–0.76

89.3

2.2

0.025

 No add. Treatment

4

0.77

0.20–1.34

64.6

2.6

0.008

 Individual best care

1

2.33

1.93–3.38

0

5.2

0.001

 Conventional

16

0.58

0.36–0.81

66.2

5.1

0.001

 Surgery

2

0.62

0.40–0.83

0

5.5

0.001

Controls

 Active

8

0.60

0.20–1.01

81.4

2.9

0.004

 No active

22

0.65

0.41–0.90

85.9

 

0.001

Cancer type

 Lung cancer

3

−0.18

−0.41–0.06

0

1.45

0.15

 Breast cancer

10

0.48

0.29–0.68

50

4.83

0.00001

Product

 Abnova V.

2

1.06

0.07–2.04

86.5

2.1

0.036

 Eurixor

4

0.94

0.32–1.60

87.7

3.0

0.003

 Helixor

3

0.35

0.13–0.57

0

3.1

0.002

 Iscador

17

0.58

0.28–0.87

88.6

3.8

0.001

 Lektinol

2

0.67

−0.13-1.48

63.4

1.6

0.1

 Other

2

0.67

0.26–1.09

0

3.2

0.001

Country

 Germany

19

0.64

0.38–0.90

80.5

4.8

0.001

 Other

11

0.64

0.30–0.98

89.4

3.7

0.001

Sponsoring

 Corporate

10

0.49

0.11–0.87

92.0

2.5

0.011

 Public

3

0.64

−0.05–1.33

91.1

1.8

0.07

 Mixed

10

0.73

0.36–1.1

35.2

3.8

0.001

 No Information

7

0.73

0.27–1.19

82.8

3.1

0.002

Type of Measure

 Index1

6

0.33

−0.12-0.78

50.1

1.4

0.1

 Scale2

14

0.71

0.41–1.0

90.9

4.6

0.001

 Self Regulation3

10

0.73

0.39–1.07

35.2

4.1

0.001

  1. aif heterogeneity > 25 random effects SMDs are given, else fixed effect
  2. b two-tailed
  3. 1 Karnofsky Index, ECOG, Spitzer QoL
  4. 2 EORTC QoL Q30, FACT, GLQ-8
  5. 3 Grossarth-Maticek’s self-regulation scale