Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison of the intensity of individual De Qi characteristics between the study groups

From: Psychophysical responses in patients receiving a mock laser within context of an acupuncture clinical trial: an interoceptive perspective

De Qi Psychophysical Characteristics

Acupuncture

Mock Laser

  

N*

Interval range

Mdn

Mean Rank

N*

Intervalrange

Mdn

Mean Rank

U

p value

1. Soreness

nil

0 - 9

4

109.1

25

0 - 6

0

51.7

1076.5

.000***

2. Aching

nil

0 - 8

2

103.6

24

0 - 7

0

60.1

1678.5

.000***

3. Deep Pressure

nil

0 - 8

3

107.3

24

0 - 6

0

55.5

1331.5

.000***

4. Heaviness

nil

0 - 8

2

104.9

24

0 - 6

0

58.5

1552.0

.000***

5. Fullness/ Distension

nil

0 - 9

3

105.7

24

0 - 7

0

57.5

1484.5

.000***

6. Tingling

nil

0 - 9

1

96.01

24

0 - 6

0

69.8

2396.0

.000***

7. Numbness

1

0 - 9

2

103.1

24

0 - 5

0

59.9

1660.5

.000***

8. Sharp Pain

nil

0 - 8

1

93.1

24

0 - 5

0

73.6

2669.5

.006**

9. Dull Pain

nil

0 - 8

1

95.1

26

0 - 9

0

68.4

2294.0

.000***

10. Warmth

nil

0 - 8

0

89.9

25

0 - 8

0

76.3

2870.5

.022*

11. Cold

nil

0 - 9

0

96.1

24

0 - 7

0

69.7

2382.0

.000***

12. Throbbing

18

0 - 7

0

82.9

27

0 - 7

0

64.4

2015.0

.000***

  1. Comparison of individual De Qi qualities mean ranks among the study groups using Mann-Whitney U test (* p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001); N* = number of missing data, Mdn = Median; Mock laser group (Centre 3) was also excluded for analysis