Skip to main content

Table 3 Scores of the candidate items

From: A survey of evidence users about the information need of acupuncture clinical evidence

Score

 

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

Mean

p (independent-sample T-test)

7.1

Total

6

9

14

17

24

18

18

48

25

72

7.2

 

Pc

2

5

1

5

9

7

7

15

11

33

7.6

0.109

NPd

4

4

13

12

15

11

11

33

14

39

7.0

 

7.2

Total

19

11

14

15

33

18

23

37

21

60

6.6

 

P

9

3

4

5

12

8

8

13

13

20

6.6

0.895

NP

10

8

10

10

21

10

15

24

8

40

6.6

 

7.3

Total

3

2

0

4

18

15

9

40

33

127

8.6

 

P

1

1

0

0

7

6

5

16

13

46

8.5

0.954

NP

2

1

0

4

11

9

4

24

20

81

8.6

 

7.4

Total

2

0

2

4

15

9

12

46

45

116

8.6

 

P

1

0

1

1

9

2

1

19

18

43

8.6

0.700

NP

1

0

1

3

6

7

11

27

27

73

8.7

 

7.5

Total

1

0

3

9

12

8

14

37

42

125

8.7

 

P

1

0

2

2

7

4

8

15

15

41

8.4

0.044

NP

0

0

1

7

5

4

6

22

27

84

8.8

 

7.6

Total

1

2

3

6

8

13

16

42

42

118

8.6

 

P

1

2

0

2

2

6

5

19

16

42

8.5

0.560

NP

0

0

3

4

6

7

11

23

26

76

8.7

 

7.7

Total

17

11

25

17

38

36

20

45

16

26

5.9

 

P

11

3

9

7

18

12

7

17

4

7

5.5

0.047

NP

6

8

16

10

20

24

13

28

12

19

6.2

 

7.8

Total

3

2

5

8

14

24

21

55

34

85

8.0

 

P

2

1

2

3

5

13

6

20

13

30

7.8

0.286

NP

1

1

3

5

9

11

15

35

21

55

8.1

 
  1. cP: Postgraduates; dNP: Non-postgraduates, including clinicians and researchers of acupuncture
  2. 7.1 Provide the theoretical basis of acupuncture used for the target disease in background/introduction
  3. 7.2 Provide the style of acupuncture treatment (e.g. traditional Chinese acupuncture, South Korean acupuncture) in background/introduction
  4. 7.3 Provide the diagnostic criteria in methods (TCM syndrome and/or diagnostic criteria of diseases according to Western medicine)
  5. 7.4 Provide types of acupuncture interventions in methods (e.g. type of acupunctures like percussopunctator and needles, and any other intervention like sham acupuncture)
  6. 7.5 Provide details of acupuncture interventions in methods (e.g. number of needles, names of acupoint, depth of puncture, relevant body response, needling manipulation, time for needle retention, types of needles)
  7. 7.6 Provide indicators of effect judgement in methods (e.g. Visual Analogue Scale (VAS))
  8. 7.7 Provide the qualification (e.g. career and other experience) of acupuncture clinicians in methods
  9. 7.8 Provide the follow-up time along with rationality in results