Skip to main content

Table 2 Overall recommendations for use of appraised guidelines

From: The quantity and quality of complementary and alternative medicine clinical practice guidelines on herbal medicines, acupuncture and spinal manipulation: systematic review and assessment using AGREE II

Guideline

Appraiser 1

Appraiser 2

Fogarty 2015 [40]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Bryans 2014 [41]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Greenlee 2014 [42]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Yadav 2014 [43]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Deng 2013 [44]

No

Yes with Modifications

Liu 2013 [45]

No

Yes with Modifications

Nahas 2013 [46]

Yes with Modifications

Yes

Holland 2012 [47]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Bryans 2011 [48]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Seffinger 2010 [49]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Deng 2009 [50]

No

Yes with Modifications

Ravindran 2009 [51]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Filshie 2006 [52]

No

No

Suchowersky 2006 [53]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Anderson-Peacock 2005 [54]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications

Werneke 2005 [55]

No

No

Mechanick 2003 [56]

Yes with Modifications

Yes with Modifications