Name of CPMs | Study ID | Diagnostic criteria | TCM pattern differentiation | Patients | Comparator | Outcomes | Adverse events |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Chaihu injection (acupoint block in T1 or intramuscular injection in T2) | Lv [9] | Guiding principle of clinical research on new drugs of traditional Chinese Medicine* | Not reported | N = 253 (100 in T1, 52 in T2, 50 in C1, and 51 in C2); M/F: not reported; Age: not reported; | C1: saline acupoint block; C2: ribavirin | Fever clearance time and cure rate | Not mentioned. |
Ganmao Qingre granules | Di [10] | Chinese clinical integrative medicine Textbook | Wind-cold type of common cold | N = 60 (30/30); M/F: 18/12 in T and 16/14 in C; Age: 6 months-12 years | Pediatric paracetamol | Cure rate | Not mentioned. |
Shuanghuanglian oral liquid | Wang [11] | Clinical symptoms and laboratory test results | Not reported | N = 100 (50/50); M/F: not reported; Age: 6 months-14 years | Ribavirin injection | Cure rate | No adverse event was identified. |
Xiaoer Baotaikang granules | Wu [12] | Criteria of diagnosis and therapeutic effect of TCM diseases* | Wind-heat type of common cold | N = 100 (50/50); M/F: not reported; Age: 4.28 ± 3.37 years in T, and 4.56 ± 3.44 years in C. | Amoxicillin granules | Cure rate | Not mentioned. |
Xiaoer Resuqing oral liquid | Li [13] | Diagnostic criteria for high fever of external contraction (Waigan Gaore in TCM syndroms)* | Not reported | N = 120 (65/55); M/F: 75/45; Age: 8 months-7 years | Moroxydine tablets | Cure rate | Not mentioned. |